Skip to main content

Filter by:


Star Rating

Review Score

Water Mill – 45 hotels and places to stay
See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.
Southampton Inn, hotel in Water Mill

Set on more than 5 acres of beautifully landscaped lawns, this Long Island hotel features a modern American restaurant with poolside service. Free summer transportation to Cooper’s Beach is available....

It was very clean and comfortable.
8.5
Scored 8.5
Very Good
Rated very good
252 reviews
Price from$370per night
Hamlet Inn, hotel in Water Mill

Just steps from Shinnecock Bay, this Southampton hotel is 2 miles from Cooper’s Beach. Hamelt Inn has a seasonal outdoor heated pool and offers free WiFi.

Place was quaint. Nice little motel set off the road on a big piece of property. Outdoor couches and two grills were available to use if we wanted to cook a meal. The rooms were clean and decorated nicely. The rooms aren't big, but for two people they were perfect and we'll probably look to stay here again.
8.1
Scored 8.1
Very Good
Rated very good
320 reviews
Price from$199per night
The Bentley Hotel Southampton, hotel in Water Mill

This Southampton, New York hotel is just 2.5 miles from Meschutt Beach County Park. It features bright suites with private terraces.

It is immaculate.
9.1
Scored 9.1
Wonderful
Rated wonderful
51 reviews
Price from$161.92per night
Southampton Long Island Hotel, hotel in Water Mill

This Southampton property is located 3 miles from Coopers Beach and features an outdoor swimming pool. Shops and restaurants in Southampton village are a 5-minute drive away.

Basic, but very clean and comfortable-“old school”
8.1
Scored 8.1
Very Good
Rated very good
116 reviews
Price from$141per night
Sea Haven Resort Motel, hotel in Water Mill

Located in Southampton, within 1.8 miles of Meschutt Beach and 17 miles of Splish Splash, Sea Haven Resort Motel provides accommodations with a garden and free WiFi as well as free private parking for...

The space was clean and comfortable enough. The showerhead was had very nice pressure.
6.8
Scored 6.8
Pleasant
Rated pleasant
33 reviews
Price from$188.10per night
The Wainscott Inn, hotel in Water Mill

The Wainscott Inn is located in Sagaponack, 12 miles from Montauk Point Lighthouse and 18 miles from Second House Museum.

Staff was wonderful
7.9
Scored 7.9
Good
Rated good
77 reviews
Price from$294per night
The 1708 House, hotel in Water Mill

Offering garden views, The 1708 House in Southampton offers accommodations and a garden.

Great location. Historic building. Rooms have real character. Cheese and wine 3-6. Lovely and quiet despite being next to a somewhat busy road.
9.6
Scored 9.6
Exceptional
Rated exceptional
178 reviews
Price from$355.50per night
Southampton Village Motel, hotel in Water Mill

Located in Southampton, 1.5 miles from Flying Point Beach, Southampton Village Motel has accommodations with free bikes, free private parking and a garden.

Location near to Main Street and bikes provided free were a nice touch.
8.0
Scored 8.0
Very Good
Rated very good
11 reviews
Price from$450per night
Harpoon House, hotel in Water Mill

Featuring a garden, Harpoon House offers accommodations in Southampton. This property offers access to a patio and free private parking.

Located right in the downtown of Southampton village great walking to town without driving.
8.4
Scored 8.4
Very Good
Rated very good
25 reviews
Price from$382.50per night
The Atlantic, hotel in Water Mill

Located on Route 27, this Southampton hotel is 2.7 miles from Tiana Beach. It provides guests with complementary passes for 10 different area beaches.

Pros: - Coffee in lobby & nice staff! - Cute grounds - Large pool (I am going to have to visit when it is open) - Clean room with fridge - Parking onsite - Close by to restaurants
7.3
Scored 7.3
Good
Rated good
169 reviews
Price from$152.90per night
See all hotels near Water Mill
Subscribe to receive premium deals

Prices drop the second you sign up!