The best available hotels & places to stay near Sugarcreek, OH

Sugarcreek – 1 hotel or place to stay

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.

Carlisle Inn

Featuring an indoor swimming pool with a retractable roof, Carlisle Inn is located in Sugarcreek, Ohio. The property serves complimentary daily breakfast.

9.3

Scored 9.3

Wonderful

Rated wonderful

134 reviews

Price from$298per night

Check availability

The Wallhouse Hotel, Ascend Hotel Collection

Walnut Creek (Ohio) (Near Sugarcreek)

Boasting a stone patio with a fire pit, The Wallhouse Hotel, Ascend Hotel Collection has free WiFi access and an indoor pool.

9.2

Scored 9.2

Wonderful

Rated wonderful

486 reviews

Price from$115.30per night

Check availability

Carlisle Inn Walnut Creek

Walnut Creek (Near Sugarcreek)

Located in Walnut Creek, Carlisle Inn Walnut Creek features a fitness center. This 4-star hotel offers a 24-hour front desk. A continental breakfast can be enjoyed at the property.

9.4

Scored 9.4

Wonderful

Rated wonderful

588 reviews

Price from$129per night

Check availability

Comfort Suites Hotel and Conference Center

Berlin (Ohio) (Near Sugarcreek)

This Comfort Suites hotel is conveniently located in downtown Berlin, surrounded by the rolling hills of Ohio's Holmes County Amish Country, which is the home to the world's largest Amish community.

9.2

Scored 9.2

Wonderful

Rated wonderful

621 reviews

Price from$138.47per night

Check availability

Berlin Encore Hotel & Suites

Millersburg (Near Sugarcreek)

Berlin Encore Hotel & Suites is located in Berlin, 18 miles from Warther Carving Museum. The hotel has an indoor pool and a 24-hour front desk and free WiFi throughout the property.

9.2

Scored 9.2

Wonderful

Rated wonderful

524 reviews

Price from$124per night

Check availability

Ramada by Wyndham Strasburg Dover

Strasburg (Ohio) (Near Sugarcreek)

Featuring free WiFi, Ramada Limited Strasburg Dover offers pet-friendly accommodations in Strasburg, 14 mi from Berlin. Each room has a TV.

8.0

Scored 8.0

Very Good

Rated very good

385 reviews

Price from$81.75per night

Check availability

Sleep Inn & Suites Mt. Hope near Auction & Event Center

Millersburg (Near Sugarcreek)

Located in Millersburg, Sleep Inn & Suites Mt. Hope near Auction & Event Center features a shared lounge, terrace and free WiFi.

9.2

Scored 9.2

Wonderful

Rated wonderful

298 reviews

Price from$126.91per night

Check availability

Best Western Dutch Valley Inn

New Philadelphia (Ohio) (Near Sugarcreek)

This New Philadelphia, Ohio hotel is located 3.5 miles from Warther Museum and has an indoor pool. The modern rooms are equipped with a refrigerator and free Wi-Fi.

7.4

Scored 7.4

Good

Rated good

158 reviews

Price from$92.65per night

Check availability

Inn at Amish Door

Wilmot (Near Sugarcreek)

Located in Wilmot, 22 miles from Pro Football Hall of Fame, Inn at Amish Door provides accommodations with a terrace, free private parking and a restaurant.

9.4

Scored 9.4

Wonderful

Rated wonderful

437 reviews

Price from$135per night

Check availability

Comfort Inn & Suites

Dover (Near Sugarcreek)

Located off of Interstate 77 (Vietnam Veterans Memorial Highway), this Comfort Inn & Suites in Dover, Ohio is 4 miles from New Philadelphia.

8.9

Scored 8.9

Excellent

Rated excellent

169 reviews

Price from$143.65per night

Check availability

See all hotels in and around Sugarcreek

What Guests Said About Sugarcreek:

8.0
Scored 8.0
I loved the broasted chicken at restaurant.
I loved the broasted chicken at restaurant. Food was suburb, along with the baked goods. Prices I paid was more expensive then other locations, (For the Room)so I guess I was paying for the Free breakfast buffet. Which was filled with calories. But coffee and tea were good. I was asked why I was going, which was my 40th wedding anniversary but nothing special was done. The play at the close by theater was excellent. Very down to earth. Use your GPS for getting around. Not so close to other towns.
Mary Carol
United States of America
10
Scored 10
The shops in Sugarcreek were nice and the restaurants were...
The shops in Sugarcreek were nice and the restaurants were great. We ate at Bags Sports Pub and had one of the best hamburgers I've every had with all the trimmings. The homemade chips were delicious. We also had a late lunch at Park Street Pizza and I can understand why this place is rated as the best pizza in the area, and oh yes, the bakery in town had delicious maple covered donuts. One was enough for a meal.
Richard
United States of America
10
Scored 10
It was much like a European village...absolutely lovely.
It was much like a European village...absolutely lovely. The Giant Coocoo Clock was fabulous. Some very nice winerys Dinning...Well of course we went to Amish Door and Boyd's...of course we ate at Dutch Valley Amish Kitchen.
Anthony
United States of America
10
Scored 10
Loved the location with the Dutch Valley Restaurant on the...
Loved the location with the Dutch Valley Restaurant on the same property and the gift shop was just darling. The hotel is off the main highway and is quiet and serene when sitting outside to take in the spectacular views.
Don
United States of America
10
Scored 10
Sugar creek area is wonderful amish community with lots of...
Sugar creek area is wonderful amish community with lots of wineries and cheese houses. Beautiful countryside and lots of quaint places to stay and things to do. Lots of shops to visit throughout the area.
John
United States of America
10
Scored 10
We loved the food ... the convenience to the restaurant /...
We loved the food ... the convenience to the restaurant / store / theater, etc. Everything from walking distance is good especially for the elderly. It is a busy place but we got around good.
Bill
United States of America

Explore guest reviews of hotels in Sugarcreek

See all

Carlisle Inn
Sugarcreek
9.3
Scored 9.3
Wonderful
Rated wonderful
· 134 reviews
Our room was spacious and had all we needed. The breakfast area was very nice although we chose to go out to eat. They had the basic hotel breakfast. Staff was friendly. The balconies for each room are wonderful!
Leslie
United States of America
Carlisle Inn
Sugarcreek
9.3
Scored 9.3
Wonderful
Rated wonderful
· 134 reviews
Great location with exceptional rooms. The balcony/porch is such a great feature with the view of farms to look out upon. It was great to have Amish quilts on the beds for a homey feel.
A
Anonymous
United States of America
Carlisle Inn
Sugarcreek
9.3
Scored 9.3
Wonderful
Rated wonderful
· 134 reviews
We love coming to the beautiful Carlisle, the hotel and the landscape are beautiful. The flowers are gorgeous, like going to a garden. It is also convenient to shop, show and eat!
A
Anonymous
United States of America
Carlisle Inn
Sugarcreek
9.3
Scored 9.3
Wonderful
Rated wonderful
· 134 reviews
Really pretty hotel. Staff especially Tiffany and Aque were very nice. Covid clean but wish required masks but large enough to social distance.
kirk
United States of America
Carlisle Inn
Sugarcreek
9.3
Scored 9.3
Wonderful
Rated wonderful
· 134 reviews
The Carlisle Inn is beautiful. The room was spacious. The evening treats and pool were wonderful. The staff was kind and welcoming.
Kristine
United States of America
Carlisle Inn
Sugarcreek
9.3
Scored 9.3
Wonderful
Rated wonderful
· 134 reviews
Beautiful hotel. The room was nice and spacious. Great location to the Amish country. Loved the small play area out front.
Beth
United States of America
Carlisle Inn
Sugarcreek
9.3
Scored 9.3
Wonderful
Rated wonderful
· 134 reviews
Very nice sitting areas throughout the hotel. Spacious rooms. Nice pool area too.
Kristine
United States of America
Carlisle Inn
Sugarcreek
9.3
Scored 9.3
Wonderful
Rated wonderful
· 134 reviews
The property itself is a beautiful setting, the hotel well-designed and welcoming.
M
Martha
United States of America
Downtown Escape Great for large families & groups
Sugarcreek
8.8
Scored 8.8
Excellent
Rated excellent
· 4 reviews
Large, close to town and all Sugarcreek and the area has to offer.
Monica
United States of America
Carlisle Inn
Sugarcreek
9.3
Scored 9.3
Wonderful
Rated wonderful
· 134 reviews
It is a very nice hotel and the staff was very friendly
Laura Lyne
United States of America