Skip to main content

Filter by:


Star Rating

Review Score

Sag Harbor – 2 hotels and places to stay
See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.
Baron's Cove, hotel in Sag Harbor

Featuring an on-site restaurant and seasonal saltwater swimming pool, Baron's Cove is located in Sag Harbor, New York.

Beautiful location on the Bay in Sag Harbor. Nice room and comfortable bed. Great location not far from Main St and all the restaurants and shops. Fun night cap with live music in the lounge / bar.
8.5
Scored 8.5
Very Good
Rated very good
114 reviews
Price from$459per night
Cowgirl Palace, hotel in Sag Harbor

Cowgirl Palace enjoys a location in Sag Harbor, 14 miles from Montauk Point Lighthouse and 19 miles from Second House Museum.

Absolutely nothing
7.2
Scored 7.2
Good
Rated good
12 reviews
Price from$200per night
Bridgehampton Inn, hotel in Sag Harbor

Bridgehampton Inn features a garden, shared lounge, a terrace and restaurant in Bridgehampton. Featuring a bar, the 5-star hotel has air-conditioned rooms with free WiFi, each with a private bathroom....

Breakfast was great which was included. We also ate at the restaurant one night for dinner. The food was fabulous and gourmet. Our room was cozy, clean and comfortable. We sat out on the deck on the first day.
9.0
Scored 9.0
Wonderful
Rated wonderful
45 reviews
Price from$535per night
The Wainscott Inn, hotel in Sag Harbor

The Wainscott Inn is located in Sagaponack, 12 miles from Montauk Point Lighthouse and 18 miles from Second House Museum.

Staff very nice
7.9
Scored 7.9
Good
Rated good
74 reviews
Price from$509per night
EHP Resort & Marina, hotel in Sag Harbor

EHP Resort & Marina is a stunning nine-acre waterfront resort, marina, and wedding and event destination in East Hampton, where the charm of modern Mediterranean influences meets the beauty of the...

Front desk attendant was impolite and impatient because when we came in to check out, she was in a phone conversation, seemed like we interpreted her, she cursed quietly (the S word) maybe because the call was dropped.
8.5
Scored 8.5
Very Good
Rated very good
36 reviews
Price from$476.10per night
Rams Head Inn, hotel in Sag Harbor

Rams Head Inn features a garden, terrace, a restaurant and bar in Shelter Island. Among the various facilities are water sports facilities and a private beach area.

Quiet, beautiful, great food, wonderful staff. We even got to meet the owner and hear more about her vision for the hotel - one which we strongly support.
8.9
Scored 8.9
Excellent
Rated excellent
8 reviews
Price from$248.17per night
Topping Rose House, hotel in Sag Harbor

Located in Bridgehampton, this hotel features a farm-to-table restaurant sourced from its own on-site farm. Guests are welcome use the property’s complimentary house vehicles, provided by Lexus.

I love the food, the residences and the space overall. Beautiful, minimal design.
7.9
Scored 7.9
Good
Rated good
14 reviews
Price from$795per night
Mill House Inn, hotel in Sag Harbor

Providing garden views, Mill House Inn in East Hampton features accommodations, a garden, and a terrace.

The staff were incredibly helpful and kind. The breakfast was excellent! Very relaxing stay in a super convenient location. Will definitely be staying again for work. 10/10 recommend.
8.3
Scored 8.3
Very Good
Rated very good
54 reviews
Price from$475per night
The Huntting Inn, hotel in Sag Harbor

1.4 miles from Egypt Beach in East Hampton, The Huntting Inn offers accommodations with access to wellness packages.

Very warm and friendly people. Nice ambiance even though was low season
7.9
Scored 7.9
Good
Rated good
44 reviews
Price from$632.50per night
The Baker House 1650, hotel in Sag Harbor

Offering a spa center and sauna, The Baker House 1650 is located in East Hampton in the New York State Region. Guests can enjoy the on-site bar.

Beautiful old school charm! Delicious food and wonderful staff. Location Location Location
9.4
Scored 9.4
Wonderful
Rated wonderful
37 reviews
Price from$700per night
See all hotels in and around Sag Harbor
Subscribe to receive premium deals

Prices drop the second you sign up!

What Guests Said About Sag Harbor:

  • 10
    Scored 10

    My first trip to Sag Harbor and staying at Baron’s Cove was...

    My first trip to Sag Harbor and staying at Baron’s Cove was a great beginning. Beautiful location, friendly staff, nice room, free bicycles, live music, great bar........they had it all. A walk through town is a must, as well as seafood from The Dock. Easily walk or bike. Had dinner at Dopo La Spiaggia and the squid ink pasta was off the charts good with a favorable wine selection. Would love to go back and stay longer!
    Ray
    United States of America