RODEWAY INN & SUITES

654 Elmira Rd., Ithaca, NY 14850 United States (USA)
View Map Reservations: 1-800-230-4134
2.0 Star Rural Hotel in Tompkins County
42.41071-76.53842
Check availability
Poor
2.5/ 5

Based on 78 guest reviews

Show Guest Reviews
  • Free breakfast available
  • 35 sleeping rooms in hotel
  • Hotel has 10 suites
  • Check in: 2:00 PM
  • Check out: 11:00 AM
  • Groups/Meetings rating of 7.5/10

Check Current Prices






Include Discounts:

Room Types

Check Rates 1 Queen Bed Free High Speed Wireless No Pets Allowed Microwave Refrigerator
Non-Smoking
Check Rates 1 Queen Bed Free High Speed Wireless Pet Friendly Room Microwave Refrigerator
Smoking
Check Rates 1 Queen Bed No Pets Allowed Free High Speed Wireless Microwave Refrigerator
Non-Smoking
Check Rates 1 Queen Free High Speed Wireless No Pets Allowed Microwave Refrigerator
Non-Smoking
Check Rates 1 Queen Free High Speed Wireless Pet Friendly Room Microwave Refrigerator Hair Dryer
Smoking
Check Rates 1 Queen No Pets Allowed Free High Speed Wireless Microwave Refrigerator
Non-Smoking
Check Rates 2 Double Beds Free High Speed Wireless Pet Friendly Room Microwave Refrigerator
Smoking
Check Rates 2 Double Beds Free High Speed Wireless Pet Friendly Room Microwave Refrigerator Hair Dryer
Smoking
Check Rates 2 Double Beds No Pets Allowed Free High Speed Wireless Microwave Refrigerator
Non-Smoking
Check Rates 2 Queen Beds Suite 1 Room Suite Partial Room Divider No Pets Allowed
Non-Smoking
Check Rates 2 Queen Suite 1 Room Suite Partial Room Divider No Pets Allowed Sofa Bed 1 Person
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Standard Double Room 2 Double Beds
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Standard Room 1 Queen Bed
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Suite
Non-Smoking

Local Attractions

Close to Buttermilk falls state park and Robert Treman state park.

Summary of Verified Reviews

Summary of 334 verified reviews

59
Poor

Close to the city center. Unpleasant furniture and bathrooms. Good internet service.

“Free fruit and coffee” “Good WIFI”

Great Budget Hotel Top 25% in city
Great City Hotel Top 25% in city

Good to know

  • Old rooms

    “Shower looked ancient” “Rooms are old”

  • Hotel is outdated

    “Shower looked ancient” “Rooms are old”

  • Room cleanliness is acceptable

    “Carpet in room could have been cleaner” “Shower was very small and dirty”

  • Bad furniture

    “Broken sofa” “Dirty carpet”

Review highlights

Location

90/100
37 reviews

Good location, more or less central.

“Close to shopping” “Close to downtown” “Close to universities”

Service

82/100
88 reviews

Warm, efficient service, good management and a fair reception.

“Staff was very pleasant and accommodating” “One staff person and he was very pleasant” “Hotel staff was very nice”

Value

76/100
71 reviews

Best value for money. Fair breakfast prices.

“Cheap place to stay” “Free fruit and coffee” “Upgraded room for free”

WiFi

75/100
12 reviews

Good internet service.

“Good WIFI” “Free wifi”

Room

44/100
172 reviews

Dirty, outdated rooms with poor TV's. Beds are standard, but furnishings and room maintenance are lacking. Small rooms and dirty bathrooms. Decently sized rooms with okay kitchenettes.

“Carpet in room could have been cleaner” “Shower was very small and dirty” “Dirty carpet”

Food

38/100
16 reviews

Food is terrible, especially the desserts.

“No waffles” “No fruit” “No bread”

Breakfast

32/100
74 reviews

Breakfast affordable but not so tasty.

“Plain bagels” “Stale cereal” “Hard boiled eggs”

Vibe

15/100
45 reviews

Atmosphere is friendly but the vibe is low. Hotel is outdated. Fine for a budget trip. Good choice for a city trip.

“Shower looked ancient” “Rooms are old” “Old TV”

Ranked top 75% by families, with a score of 63

Good to know

  • Food is not good

    “No waffles” “No fruit”

  • Friendly service

    “Personable staff” “Very accommodating staff”

  • Bad furniture

    “Broken sofa” “Dirty carpet”

  • Poor bathroom

    “Toilet didn't work” “Shower was very small and dirty”

Review highlights

Service

84/100
15 reviews

Friendly service.

“Staff was very pleasant and accommodating” “One staff person and he was very pleasant” “Hotel staff was very nice”

Value

74/100
11 reviews

Best value for money.

“Cheap place to stay” “Free fruit and coffee” “Upgraded room for free”

Comfort

61/100
14 reviews

Room size and comfort are OK, but beds are great.

“Calm environment” “Noisy AC” “Heating system loud”

Cleanliness

52/100
13 reviews

Room cleanliness is acceptable.

“Linens clean” “Shower it was so dirty” “Dirty carpet”

Room

50/100
24 reviews

Rooms in need of maintenance, with bad bathrooms and furniture. Rooms are of average size, and moderately well-maintained, with nice beds.

“Carpet in room could have been cleaner” “Shower was very small and dirty” “Dirty carpet”

Food

38/100
4 reviews

Food is not good.

“No waffles” “No fruit” “No bread”

Bar

30/100
5 reviews

Bar is not good.

“No decaf coffee” “No tea” “Barely any milk”

Breakfast

29/100
12 reviews

Bad breakfast.

“Plain bagels” “Stale cereal” “Hard boiled eggs”

Vibe

19/100
7 reviews

Poor vibe. Hotel is outdated.

“Shower looked ancient” “Rooms are old” “Old TV”

Ranked top 80% by couples, with a score of 66

Good to know

  • Old rooms

    “Shower looked ancient” “Rooms are old”

  • Great location

    “Close to shopping” “Close to downtown”

  • Hotel is outdated

    “Shower looked ancient” “Rooms are old”

  • Poor vibe

    “Shower looked ancient” “Rooms are old”

Review highlights

Location

86/100
10 reviews

Great location.

“Close to shopping” “Close to downtown” “Close to universities”

Service

85/100
9 reviews

Fantastic service.

“Staff was very pleasant and accommodating” “One staff person and he was very pleasant” “Hotel staff was very nice”

Value

73/100
10 reviews

Best value for money.

“Cheap place to stay” “Free fruit and coffee” “Upgraded room for free”

Comfort

54/100
12 reviews

Beds are decent and generally comfortable.

“Calm environment” “Noisy AC” “Heating system loud”

Cleanliness

51/100
10 reviews

Room cleanliness is acceptable.

“Linens clean” “Smelly carpet” “Shower it was so dirty”

Room

42/100
20 reviews

Rooms are old and bathrooms are unpleasant, but beds and room cleanliness are okay.

“Carpet in room could have been cleaner” “Shower was very small and dirty” “Dirty carpet”

Breakfast

29/100
12 reviews

Bad breakfast.

“Plain bagels” “Stale cereal” “Hard boiled eggs”

Vibe

12/100
7 reviews

Poor vibe. Hotel is outdated.

“Shower looked ancient” “Rooms are old” “Old TV”

Ranked top 73% by business travelers, with a score of 57

Good to know

  • Best value for money

    “Cheap place to stay” “Free fruit and coffee”

  • Fantastic service

    “Staff was very pleasant and accommodating” “One staff person and he was very pleasant”

  • Room cleanliness is acceptable

    “Carpet in room could have been cleaner” “Shower was very small and dirty”

  • Room is not nice

    “Carpet in room could have been cleaner” “Shower was very small and dirty”

Review highlights

Service

85/100
5 reviews

Fantastic service.

“Staff was very pleasant and accommodating” “One staff person and he was very pleasant” “Hotel staff was very nice”

Value

78/100
6 reviews

Best value for money.

“Cheap place to stay” “Free fruit and coffee” “Upgraded room for free”

Comfort

58/100
9 reviews

Beds are decent and generally comfortable.

“Calm environment” “Noisy AC” “Heating system loud”

Room

47/100
9 reviews

Room is not nice. Rooms are quite clean and beds are standard.

“Carpet in room could have been cleaner” “Shower was very small and dirty” “Dirty carpet”

Ranked top 91% by solo travelers, with a score of 55

Good to know

  • Room is not nice

    “Carpet in room could have been cleaner” “Shower was very small and dirty”

Review highlights

Room

44/100
4 reviews

Room is not nice.

“Carpet in room could have been cleaner” “Shower was very small and dirty” “Dirty carpet”

Good to know

  • Old rooms

    “Shower looked ancient” “Rooms are old”

  • Hotel is outdated

    “Shower looked ancient” “Rooms are old”

  • Bad furniture

    “Broken sofa” “Dirty carpet”

  • Small rooms

    “Shower was very small and dirty” “Very small room”

Review highlights

Location

94/100
32 reviews

Near city centre in a great location.

“Close to shopping” “Close to downtown” “Close to universities”

Service

81/100
80 reviews

Reception is typical, although management is stand-out and service is friendly.

“Staff was very pleasant and accommodating” “One staff person and he was very pleasant” “Hotel staff was very nice”

WiFi

71/100
9 reviews

Good internet service.

“Good WIFI” “Free wifi”

Cleanliness

51/100
87 reviews

Room and bathroom cleanliness is lacking. Moderately clean hotel facilities.

“The place was clean” “Shower was very small and dirty” “Dirty carpet”

Room

46/100
163 reviews

Beds are OK and rooms are quite clean, but unmaintained and cramped. Small rooms and dirty bathrooms. Old rooms with poor TV's and furniture but OK kitchenettes.

“Carpet in room could have been cleaner” “Shower was very small and dirty” “Dirty carpet”

Food

38/100
16 reviews

Food is terrible, especially the desserts.

“No waffles” “No fruit” “No bread”

Breakfast

34/100
66 reviews

Breakfast affordable but not so tasty.

“Plain bagels” “Stale cereal” “Hard boiled eggs”

Vibe

16/100
43 reviews

Atmosphere is friendly but the vibe is low. Hotel is outdated.

“Shower looked ancient” “Rooms are old” “Old TV”

Ranked top 75% by families, with a score of 62

Good to know

  • Food is not good

    “No waffles” “No fruit”

  • Friendly service

    “Personable staff” “Very accommodating staff”

  • Bad furniture

    “Broken sofa” “Dirty carpet”

  • Poor bathroom

    “Toilet didn't work” “Shower was very small and dirty”

Review highlights

Service

84/100
14 reviews

Friendly service.

“Staff was very pleasant and accommodating” “One staff person and he was very pleasant” “Hotel staff was very nice”

Comfort

60/100
12 reviews

Room size and comfort are OK, but beds are great.

“Calm environment” “Tight space” “Noisy AC”

Cleanliness

52/100
13 reviews

Room cleanliness is acceptable.

“Linens clean” “Hair in shower” “Dirty carpet”

Room

49/100
22 reviews

Rooms in need of maintenance, with bad bathrooms and furniture. Rooms are of average size, and moderately well-maintained, with nice beds.

“Carpet in room could have been cleaner” “Shower was very small and dirty” “Dirty carpet”

Food

38/100
4 reviews

Food is not good.

“No waffles” “No fruit” “No bread”

Bar

30/100
5 reviews

Bar is not good.

“No decaf coffee” “No tea” “Barely any milk”

Breakfast

29/100
11 reviews

Bad breakfast.

“Plain bagels” “Stale cereal” “Hard boiled eggs”

Vibe

19/100
7 reviews

Poor vibe. Hotel is outdated.

“Shower looked ancient” “Rooms are old” “Old TV”

Ranked top 80% by couples, with a score of 65

Good to know

  • Great location

    “Close to shopping” “Close to downtown”

  • Hotel is outdated

    “Shower looked ancient” “Rooms are old”

  • Poor vibe

    “Shower looked ancient” “Rooms are old”

  • Bad breakfast

    “Plain bagels” “Stale cereal”

Review highlights

Location

90/100
7 reviews

Great location.

“Close to shopping” “Close to downtown” “Close to universities”

Service

84/100
5 reviews

Fantastic service.

“Staff was very pleasant and accommodating” “One staff person and he was very pleasant” “Hotel staff was very nice”

Value

73/100
7 reviews

Best value for money.

“Cheap place to stay” “Free fruit and coffee” “Upgraded room for free”

Comfort

54/100
11 reviews

Beds are decent and generally comfortable.

“Calm environment” “Tight space” “Noisy AC”

Cleanliness

51/100
10 reviews

Room cleanliness is acceptable.

“The place was clean” “Clean towels” “Shower was very small and dirty”

Room

43/100
17 reviews

Bad rooms with terrible bathrooms. Rooms are quite clean and beds are standard.

“Carpet in room could have been cleaner” “Shower was very small and dirty” “Dirty carpet”

Breakfast

30/100
9 reviews

Bad breakfast.

“Plain bagels” “Stale cereal” “Hard boiled eggs”

Vibe

13/100
5 reviews

Poor vibe. Hotel is outdated.

“Shower looked ancient” “Rooms are old” “Old TV”

Good to know

  • Fantastic service

    “Staff was very pleasant and accommodating” “One staff person and he was very pleasant”

  • Room is not nice

    “Carpet in room could have been cleaner” “Shower was very small and dirty”

Review highlights

Service

85/100
5 reviews

Fantastic service.

“Staff was very pleasant and accommodating” “One staff person and he was very pleasant” “Hotel staff was very nice”

Value

78/100
6 reviews

Best value for money.

“Cheap place to stay” “Free fruit and coffee” “Upgraded room for free”

Comfort

62/100
9 reviews

Beds are decent and generally comfortable.

“Calm environment” “Noisy AC” “Heating system loud”

Room

47/100
9 reviews

Room is not nice. Rooms are quite clean and beds are standard.

“Carpet in room could have been cleaner” “Shower was very small and dirty” “Dirty carpet”

Review Semantics by TrustYou

Customer Reviews of Rodeway Inn & Suites

2.5 out of 5. Based on 78 guest reviews , Poor

Details / Other Expenses

Check In: 2:00 PM
Check Out: 11:00 AM
Year of Last Renovation: 2010
Floors: 1
Rooms: 35
Corridors: All Rooms Have Exterior Hallways
Suites: 10
Room Windows: Windows Do Open
Cleaning Frequency: Daily
Meeting Rooms: 0
Dist. to Food/Bars: 1.0 Mi
Dist. to 24hr Restaurant: 3.0 Mi
Dist. to Nearest Gym: 2.0 Mi
Policies / Expenses
Nightly Parking: 0
Total Taxes: 13.00%
Total Misc Fees: $0.00 USD
(mandatory resort fees/taxes)

Amenities / Features


Pet Friendly? Yes! Pets are allowed.
$10.00 per pet, per night.


  • Air conditioning
  • Alarm clock
  • Complimentary breakfast
  • Complimentary newspaper
  • Credit card accepted: Mastercard/Visa
  • Credit card accepted: American Express
  • Credit card accepted: Discover
  • Credit card accepted: Diners Club
  • Credit card accepted: JCB
  • Electronic key card
  • Fax available
  • Free local calls
  • Hairdryer available
  • Ice Maker
  • Internet - wireless
  • Internet - ethernet
  • Internet is Complimentary
  • Microwave in room
  • Non-smoking rooms
  • 24 hours opened
  • Pets allowed
  • Private bathroom in room
  • Quiet location
  • Refrigerator
  • Shower
  • Telephone in all rooms
  • Television
  • TV - Free Cable
  • TV - Free HBO

Airport & Shuttle Information

Ithaca Airport 8 miles.

Airport Shuttle? Sorry, no airport shuttle available.

About Rodeway Inn

  • Wake up to free coffee every morning
  • Free local calls and long distance access
  • Premium movie channel at no extra cost
  • Free high-speed internet service

The Rodeway Inn highlights above are subject to change without notice.

People also viewed these hotels

More Details >
Image of Ramada Inn
Ramada Inn ~5.78 Miles away

Testimonials: Why use Hotel Planner?

Testimonials icon
"Thank you for the referral, and I really, realy like your site/service. You can count on me to pass word along to anyone else that I meet who is booking a meeting." O.H. - Las Vegas, NV

Find out more Check Rates