BANANA BAY RESORT & MARINA

4590 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 33050 United States (USA)
View Map Reservations: 1-800-230-4134
2.5 Star Rural Spa or Beach Resort in Monroe County
24.71411-81.08383
Check availability
Average
3.0/ 5

Based on 462 guest reviews

Show Guest Reviews
  • Has an outdoor pool!
  • Complimentary breakfast is offered
  • The Avg. Group Discount is 47.5%!
  • 62 sleeping rooms in hotel
  • 2 floors in hotel
  • Check out: 11am
  • Group friendly rating of 10.0/10
  • 2 meeting rooms in property

Check Current Prices






Include Discounts:

Room Types

Check Rates Accessible Island Resort View King Bed Free WiFi Mini Fridge Max 3 Ppl
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Accessible Marina Gulf View King Bed Free WiFi Mini Fridge Max 3 Ppl
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Accessible Marina Resort View King Bed Free WiFi Mini Fridge Roll in Shower Max 3 Ppl
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Classic Room 1 King Bed Accessible Resort View
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Classic Room 1 King Bed Balcony Resort View
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Classic Room 1 King Bed Resort View
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Classic Room 2 Queen Beds Balcony Resort View
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Classic Room 2 Queen Beds Resort View
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Gulf View Accessible King
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Gulf View King
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Gulf View King with Balcony
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Gulf View Queen with Balcony
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Island Resort View 2 Queen Beds Free WiFi Balcony Coffee Maker Max 5 Ppl
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Island Resort View 2 Queen Beds Free WiFi Mini Fridge Coffee Maker Max 5 Ppl
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Island Resort View King Bed Balcony Free WiFi Mini Fridge Coffee Maker Max 3 Ppl
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Island Resort View King Bed Free WiFi Mini Fridge Max 3 Ppl
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Marina Gulf View 2 Queen Beds Balcony Free WiFi Mini Fridge Coffee Maker Max 5 Ppl
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Marina Gulf View King Bed Balcony Free WiFi Mini Fridge Coffee Maker Max 3 Ppl
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Marina Pool View 2 Queen Beds Balcony Free WiFi Mini Fridge Coffee Maker Max 5 Ppl
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Marina Pool View King Bed Balcony Free WiFi Mini Fridge Coffee Maker Max 3 Ppl
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Marina Resort View 2 Queen Beds Balcony Free WiFi Mini Fridge Coffee Maker Max 5 Ppl
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Marina Resort View King Bed Balcony Free WiFi Mini Fridge Coffee Maker Max 3 Ppl
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Pool View King
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Pool View Queen
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Resort View 2 Queen
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Resort View 2 Queen with Balcony
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Resort View Accessible King
Non-Smoking
Check Rates Resort View King
Non-Smoking

Local Attractions

Crane Point Hammock, Bahia Honda State Park, also only an hours drive to John Pennecamp, and Key West

Summary of Verified Reviews

Good to know

  • Pleasant hotel grounds

    “Serene surroundings” “Tennis courts and rooms were comfortable”

  • Hotel is outdated

    “This place is old and run down” “Very old motel”

  • Poor hotel buildings

    “Dated property” “Completely worn out carpeting at stairs”

  • Great view

    “Beautiful water views” “Beautiful view of ocean”

Review highlights

Wellness

92/100
53 reviews

Great wellness & sports facilities.

“Hot tub worked great” “Hot tub is big and powerful” “Also large hot tub”

Location

92/100
293 reviews

Great location. Great nearby restaurants and bars with excellent excursions. Close to the beach, with great shopping and sightseeing nearby. Fairly accessible by car with easy parking.

“Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge” “Fantastic location”

Pool

77/100
339 reviews

Great but dirty pool.

“Pool and hot tub were excellent” “Pool area was awesome” “Pool was beautiful and very clean”

Service

74/100
258 reviews

Friendly, fairly professional service, with an OK reception and particularly good bar service. Disorganized booking process.

“Staff was very informative” “Staff were friendly and helpful” “Delightful staff”

Value

60/100
135 reviews

Fairly good value for money.

“Recommend this affordable resort” “Reasonably priced and clean place to stay” “Reasonably priced for the Keys”

Amenities

56/100
298 reviews

Hotel grounds are nice, but the entrance area isn't, and amenities are decent but outdated. Unspectacular architecture. Bad outdoor sports facilities.

“Floors have been vacuumed” “No A/C in the hallways” “Completely worn out carpeting at stairs”

Room

55/100
691 reviews

Room is acceptably new, and beds are so-so. Rooms are dirty and neglected with bad minibars. Large rooms, good TV's, and great views. Rooms are poorly-furnished, with unsightly furnishings, dirty bathrooms and bad A/C.

“Air conditioner worked great” “Carpet is stained” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

Vibe

53/100
260 reviews

OK vibe and a friendly atmosphere. Hotel is outdated. Unpleasant entrance area. Stylish Hotel. Nice boutique hotel. Good resort hotel.

“AC was newer” “Modern shower head” “Modern decoration”

Beach

49/100
44 reviews

Beach is poor. No good beach sports.

“No water sports” “No snorkeling area” “No fishing equipment”

Cleanliness

40/100
345 reviews

Dirty rooms, bathrooms, and pool area. Unclean hotel facilities.

“Carpet is stained” “Moldy bath fixtures” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

Bar

39/100
105 reviews

Poor bar with bad drinks. Good bar service.

“No food at the Tiki bar” “No alcohol” “Coffee in room would have been nice”

WiFi

34/100
48 reviews

Bad internet service.

“Wi-fi didn't work” “POOR INTERNET” “Wifi not working”

Breakfast

27/100
30 reviews

Bad breakfast.

“No poolside breakfast” “No continential breakfast” “No continetal breakfast”

Ranked top 51% by couples, with a score of 71

Good to know

  • Unpleasant entrance area

    “No elevator” “Muggy halls”

  • Bad breakfast

    “No poolside breakfast” “No continential breakfast”

  • Old facilities

    “Older building” “Buildings are old”

  • Bad kitchenette

    “No microwave”

Review highlights

Location

95/100
110 reviews

Great location, excursions, and parking.

“Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge” “Fantastic location”

Wellness

91/100
11 reviews

Great wellness & sports facilities.

“Hot tub worked great” “Hot tub is big and powerful” “Also large hot tub”

Service

77/100
86 reviews

Service is acceptably professional but very friendly, with decent reception and housekeeping.

“Staff was very informative” “Staff were friendly and helpful” “Delightful staff”

Pool

75/100
108 reviews

Great but dirty pool.

“Pool and hot tub were excellent” “Pool area was awesome” “Pool was beautiful and very clean”

Value

59/100
35 reviews

Fairly good value for money.

“Recommend this affordable resort” “Reasonably priced and clean place to stay” “Charge a lot of”

Vibe

57/100
94 reviews

OK vibe and a friendly atmosphere. Hotel is outdated. Stylish Hotel. Unpleasant entrance area.

“AC was newer” “Modern shower head” “Modern decoration”

Amenities

57/100
100 reviews

Hotel grounds are nice, but the entrance area isn't, and amenities are decent but outdated. Unspectacular architecture.

“Completely worn out carpeting at stairs” “Stained carpets” “Hallways filthy”

Room

54/100
242 reviews

Spacious, moderately new rooms, with nice views but average beds. Neglected, dirty rooms. Rooms are poorly-furnished, with unsightly furnishings, dirty bathrooms and bad A/C. Standard TV's and decent balconies.

“Air conditioner worked great” “Carpet is stained” “Carpeting is disgusting”

Beach

49/100
14 reviews

Beach is poor.

“No water sports” “No snorkeling area” “No fishing equipment”

Bar

40/100
37 reviews

Bar is not good.

“No food at the Tiki bar” “No alcohol” “Coffee in room would have been nice”

Cleanliness

35/100
116 reviews

Dirty rooms, bathrooms, and pool area. Unclean hotel facilities.

“Carpet is stained” “Moldy bath fixtures” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

WiFi

31/100
18 reviews

Bad internet service.

“Wi-fi didn't work” “POOR INTERNET” “Wifi not working”

Breakfast

28/100
13 reviews

Bad breakfast.

“No poolside breakfast” “No continential breakfast” “No continetal breakfast”

Ranked top 35% by families, with a score of 73

Good to know

  • Bad air conditioning

    “Noisy AC” “Air conditioner was super loud”

  • Bad furniture

    “Carpet is stained” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

  • Bad internet service

    “Wi-fi didn't work” “POOR INTERNET”

  • Great wellness & sports facilities

    “Hot tub worked great” “Hot tub is big and powerful”

Review highlights

Wellness

93/100
8 reviews

Great wellness & sports facilities.

“Hot tub worked great” “Hot tub is big and powerful” “Also large hot tub”

Location

89/100
44 reviews

Excellent location with good excursion options.

“Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge” “Fantastic location”

Pool

77/100
56 reviews

Great but dirty pool.

“Pool and hot tub were excellent” “Pool area was awesome” “Pool was beautiful and very clean”

Service

71/100
37 reviews

Beds and cleanliness are decent, but rooms look old and poorly-furnished.

“Staff was very informative” “Staff were friendly and helpful” “Delightful staff”

Vibe

58/100
32 reviews

OK vibe and a friendly atmosphere. Relatively modern hotel.

“AC was newer” “Modern shower head” “Modern decoration”

Amenities

57/100
40 reviews

Hotel buildings are unacceptable but amenities are OK.

“Muggy halls” “No A/C in the hallways” “Completely worn out carpeting at stairs”

Value

57/100
15 reviews

Fairly good value for money.

“Recommend this affordable resort” “Reasonably priced and clean place to stay” “Not worth the stay”

Room

53/100
102 reviews

Spacious, moderately new rooms, with nice views but average beds. Dirty, run-down rooms with horrible A/C and furniture.

“Air conditioner worked great” “Carpet is stained” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

Beach

49/100
6 reviews

Beach is poor.

“No water sports” “No snorkeling area” “No fishing equipment”

Cleanliness

39/100
44 reviews

Unclean rooms and pool area. Unclean hotel facilities.

“Carpet is stained” “Moldy bath fixtures” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

WiFi

32/100
9 reviews

Bad internet service.

“Wi-fi didn't work” “POOR INTERNET” “Wifi not working”

Ranked top 13% by solo travelers, with a score of 81

Good to know

  • Great location

    “Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge”

  • Friendly service

    “Very friendly host” “Friendly staff”

  • Dirty room

    “Carpet is stained” “Pillows were stained”

  • Hotel is outdated

    “This place is old and run down” “Very old motel”

Review highlights

Location

94/100
11 reviews

Great location.

“Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge” “Fantastic location”

Pool

76/100
8 reviews

Great pool.

“Pool and hot tub were excellent” “Pool area was awesome” “Pool was beautiful and very clean”

Service

76/100
10 reviews

Friendly service.

“Staff was very informative” “Staff were friendly and helpful” “Delightful staff”

Room

60/100
16 reviews

Rooms are acceptable but filthy.

“Excellent shower” “Air conditioner worked great” “Carpet is stained”

Amenities

57/100
8 reviews

Hotel buildings are unacceptable but amenities are OK.

“Completely worn out carpeting at stairs” “Dirty floors” “Hallways filthy”

Value

57/100
5 reviews

Fairly good value for money.

“Recommend this affordable resort” “Reasonably priced and clean place to stay” “Not worth the stay”

Vibe

54/100
8 reviews

Decent vibe. Hotel is outdated.

“AC was newer” “Modern shower head” “Modern decoration”

Cleanliness

45/100
7 reviews

Dirty room.

“Carpet is stained” “Moldy bath fixtures” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

Good to know

  • Poor hotel buildings

    “Dated property” “Completely worn out carpeting at stairs”

  • Hotel is outdated

    “This place is old and run down” “Very old motel”

  • Friendly atmosphere

    “Tropical atmosphere” “Tropical feeling”

  • Poor bathroom

    “No water pressure” “Hair dryer did not work”

Review highlights

Location

94/100
12 reviews

Great location.

“Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge” “Fantastic location”

Pool

79/100
14 reviews

Great pool.

“Pool and hot tub were excellent” “Pool area was awesome” “Pool was beautiful and very clean”

Service

68/100
10 reviews

Service is adequate.

“Staff was very friendly” “Lack of security” “No food services”

Comfort

64/100
19 reviews

Reasonably comfortable rooms with a tolerable noise level and standard beds. Spacious rooms.

“AC was newer” “Mattress needs to be updated” “No A/C in the hallways”

Value

62/100
9 reviews

Fairly good value for money.

“Recommend this affordable resort” “Reasonably priced and clean place to stay” “Reasonably priced for the Keys”

Amenities

57/100
9 reviews

Hotel buildings are unacceptable but amenities are OK.

“No A/C in the hallways” “Completely worn out carpeting at stairs” “Halls were dirty”

Room

56/100
38 reviews

So-so beds and decent, big rooms. Filthy rooms with unacceptable bathrooms.

“AC worked great” “Carpet is stained” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

Vibe

56/100
13 reviews

OK vibe and a friendly atmosphere. Hotel is outdated.

“AC was newer” “Modern shower head” “Modern decoration”

WiFi

36/100
5 reviews

Bad internet service.

“Wi-fi didn't work” “POOR INTERNET” “Wifi not working”

Cleanliness

34/100
12 reviews

Dirty room.

“Carpet is stained” “Moldy bath fixtures” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

Breakfast

25/100
7 reviews

Bad breakfast.

“No poolside breakfast” “No continential breakfast” “No continetal breakfast”

Ranked top 34% by couples, with a score of 74

Good to know

  • Great pool

    “Pool and hot tub were excellent” “Pool area was awesome”

  • Great location

    “Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge”

  • Hotel is outdated

    “This place is old and run down” “Very old motel”

  • Dirty

    “Carpet is stained” “Moldy bath fixtures”

Review highlights

Location

93/100
6 reviews

Great location.

“Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge” “Fantastic location”

Pool

80/100
5 reviews

Great pool.

“Pool and hot tub were excellent” “Pool area was awesome” “Pool was beautiful and very clean”

Service

69/100
6 reviews

Service is adequate.

“Staff were very friendly” “Lack of security” “No food services”

Value

63/100
6 reviews

Fairly good value for money.

“Recommend this affordable resort” “Reasonably priced and clean place to stay” “Not worth the stay”

Comfort

59/100
7 reviews

Comfortable.

“AC was newer” “Air conditioner worked great” “Mattress needs to be updated”

Amenities

57/100
6 reviews

Hotel buildings are unacceptable but amenities are OK.

“Completely worn out carpeting at stairs” “Smelly buildings” “Hallways filthy”

Vibe

54/100
9 reviews

Decent vibe. Hotel is outdated.

“AC was newer” “Modern shower head” “Modern decoration”

Room

52/100
19 reviews

Rooms are acceptable but filthy.

“Air conditioner worked great” “Moldy bath fixtures” “Perfect plumbing fixtures”

Cleanliness

40/100
7 reviews

Dirty room.

“Carpet is stained” “Moldy bath fixtures” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

Ranked top 75% by families, with a score of 67

Review highlights

Comfort

61/100
4 reviews

Comfortable.

“AC was newer” “Air conditioner was super loud” “Mattress needs to be updated”

Room

54/100
7 reviews

Room is all right.

“Excellent shower” “Air conditioner worked great” “Carpet is stained”

Good to know

  • Pleasant hotel grounds

    “Serene surroundings” “Tennis courts and rooms were comfortable”

  • Hotel is outdated

    “This place is old and run down” “Very old motel”

  • Poor hotel buildings

    “Dated property” “Completely worn out carpeting at stairs”

  • Great view

    “Beautiful water views” “Beautiful view of ocean”

Review highlights

Wellness

92/100
51 reviews

Great wellness & sports facilities.

“Hot tub worked great” “Hot tub is big and powerful” “Also large hot tub”

Location

91/100
247 reviews

Great location somewhat accessible by car. Great nearby restaurants and bars with excellent excursions. Close to the beach, with great shopping and sightseeing nearby.

“Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge” “Fantastic location”

Pool

79/100
283 reviews

Great but dirty pool.

“Pool and hot tub were excellent” “Pool area was awesome” “Pool was beautiful and very clean”

Service

77/100
227 reviews

Service and bar service are friendly. Service, housekeeping and reception are all fine. Disorganized booking process.

“Staff was very informative” “Staff were friendly and helpful” “Delightful staff”

Value

60/100
111 reviews

Fairly good value for money.

“Recommend this affordable resort” “Reasonably priced and clean place to stay” “Not worth the stay”

Room

56/100
590 reviews

Room is acceptably new, and beds are so-so. Rooms are dirty and neglected with bad minibars. Large rooms, good TV's, and great views. Rooms are poorly-furnished, with unsightly furnishings, dirty bathrooms and bad A/C.

“Air conditioner worked great” “Perfect plumbing fixtures” “Beautiful water views”

Amenities

55/100
254 reviews

Hotel grounds are nice, but the entrance area isn't, and amenities are decent but outdated. Unspectacular architecture. Bad outdoor sports facilities.

“No A/C in the hallways” “Completely worn out carpeting at stairs” “Poorly maintained facilities”

Vibe

52/100
220 reviews

OK vibe and a friendly atmosphere. Hotel is outdated. Unpleasant entrance area. Stylish Hotel.

“AC was newer” “Modern shower head” “Modern decoration”

Food

48/100
86 reviews

Food is not good. Great desserts & fruits.

“No restaurant on the property” “Cracked Conch” “No food at the Tiki bar”

Cleanliness

44/100
302 reviews

Dirty rooms, bathrooms, and pool area. Unclean hotel facilities.

“Carpet is stained” “Moldy bath fixtures” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

Beach

44/100
37 reviews

Beach is poor. No good beach sports.

“No water sports” “No snorkeling area” “No fishing equipment”

Bar

38/100
100 reviews

Poor bar with bad drinks. Good bar service.

“No food at the Tiki bar” “No alcohol” “Coffee in room would have been nice”

WiFi

34/100
38 reviews

Bad internet service.

“Wi-fi didn't work” “POOR INTERNET” “Wifi not working”

Breakfast

29/100
20 reviews

Bad breakfast.

“No poolside breakfast” “No continential breakfast” “No continetal breakfast”

Ranked top 46% by couples, with a score of 73

Good to know

  • Unpleasant entrance area

    “No elevator” “Muggy halls”

  • Spacious rooms

    “Large flat screen” “Large mirror on wall”

  • Bad breakfast

    “No poolside breakfast” “No continential breakfast”

  • Old facilities

    “Older building” “Buildings are old”

Review highlights

Location

94/100
89 reviews

Great location, excursions, and parking.

“Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge” “Fantastic location”

Wellness

91/100
11 reviews

Great wellness & sports facilities.

“Hot tub worked great” “Hot tub is big and powerful” “Also large hot tub”

Service

81/100
69 reviews

Service is acceptably professional but very friendly, with decent reception and housekeeping.

“Staff was very informative” “Staff were friendly and helpful” “Delightful staff”

Pool

78/100
86 reviews

Great but dirty pool.

“Pool and hot tub were excellent” “Pool area was awesome” “Pool was beautiful and very clean”

Value

59/100
22 reviews

Fairly good value for money.

“Recommend this affordable resort” “Reasonably priced and clean place to stay” “Not worth the stay”

Amenities

57/100
76 reviews

Hotel grounds are nice, but the entrance area isn't, and amenities are decent but outdated. Unspectacular architecture.

“No A/C in the hallways” “Completely worn out carpeting at stairs” “Poorly maintained facilities”

Vibe

56/100
69 reviews

OK vibe and a friendly atmosphere. Hotel is outdated. Stylish Hotel. Unpleasant entrance area.

“AC was newer” “Modern shower head” “Modern decoration”

Room

55/100
190 reviews

Average rooms with okay beds and TVs. Big rooms with lovely views, but poorly-maintained with poor furniture. Bathrooms and rooms are untidy.

“Excellent shower” “AC worked great” “Carpet is stained”

Beach

48/100
10 reviews

Beach is poor.

“No water sports” “No snorkeling area” “No fishing equipment”

Bar

41/100
36 reviews

Bar is not good.

“No food at the Tiki bar” “No alcohol” “Coffee in room would have been nice”

Cleanliness

39/100
89 reviews

Dirty rooms, bathrooms, and pool area. Unclean hotel facilities.

“Carpet is stained” “Moldy bath fixtures” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

WiFi

31/100
16 reviews

Bad internet service.

“Wi-fi didn't work” “POOR INTERNET” “Wifi not working”

Breakfast

29/100
8 reviews

Bad breakfast.

“No poolside breakfast” “No continential breakfast” “No continetal breakfast”

Ranked top 37% by families, with a score of 74

Good to know

  • Bad air conditioning

    “Noisy AC” “Air conditioner was super loud”

  • Unclean hotel facilities

    “Carpets dirty and stained” “Hallways filthy”

  • Bad furniture

    “Carpet is stained” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

  • Friendly service

    “Very friendly host” “Friendly staff”

Review highlights

Wellness

93/100
6 reviews

Great wellness & sports facilities.

“Hot tub worked great” “Hot tub is big and powerful” “Also large hot tub”

Location

88/100
29 reviews

Excellent location with good excursion options.

“Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge” “Fantastic location”

Pool

75/100
38 reviews

Great but dirty pool.

“Pool and hot tub were excellent” “Pool area was awesome” “Pool was beautiful and very clean”

Service

72/100
30 reviews

Beds and cleanliness are decent, but rooms look old and poorly-furnished.

“Staff was very informative” “Staff were friendly and helpful” “Delightful staff”

Vibe

58/100
24 reviews

OK vibe and a friendly atmosphere. Relatively modern hotel.

“AC was newer” “Modern shower head” “Modern decoration”

Value

58/100
11 reviews

Fairly good value for money.

“Recommend this affordable resort” “Reasonably priced and clean place to stay” “Not worth the stay”

Amenities

55/100
31 reviews

Hotel buildings are unacceptable but amenities are OK.

“Muggy halls” “No A/C in the hallways” “Completely worn out carpeting at stairs”

Room

54/100
79 reviews

Rooms are fine with okay beds, but run down with shoddy furniture. Dirty rooms with bad A/C. Great view.

“Excellent shower” “Air conditioner worked great” “Carpet is stained”

Cleanliness

41/100
38 reviews

Unclean rooms and pool area. Unclean hotel facilities.

“Carpet is stained” “Moldy bath fixtures” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

WiFi

35/100
4 reviews

Bad internet service.

“Wi-fi didn't work” “POOR INTERNET” “Wifi not working”

Ranked top 10% by solo travelers, with a score of 81

Good to know

  • Great location

    “Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge”

  • Hotel is outdated

    “This place is old and run down” “Very old motel”

  • Dirty room

    “Carpet is stained” “Pillows were stained”

  • Dirty

    “Carpet is stained” “Moldy bath fixtures”

Review highlights

Location

94/100
7 reviews

Great location.

“Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge” “Fantastic location”

Pool

76/100
5 reviews

Great pool.

“Pool and hot tub were excellent” “Pool area was awesome” “Pool was beautiful and very clean”

Service

76/100
7 reviews

Fantastic service.

“Staff was very informative” “Staff were friendly and helpful” “Delightful staff”

Room

61/100
13 reviews

Rooms are acceptable but filthy.

“Air conditioner worked great” “Carpet is stained” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

Amenities

56/100
6 reviews

Hotel buildings are unacceptable but amenities are OK.

“No A/C in the hallways” “Completely worn out carpeting at stairs” “Halls were dirty”

Vibe

54/100
7 reviews

Decent vibe. Hotel is outdated.

“AC was newer” “Modern shower head” “Modern decoration”

Cleanliness

48/100
5 reviews

Dirty room.

“Carpet is stained” “Moldy bath fixtures” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

Good to know

  • Dirty pool

    “Pool dirty” “Pool was filthy”

  • Hotel is outdated

    “This place is old and run down” “Very old motel”

  • Dirty bathroom

    “Moldy bath fixtures” “Dirty towels”

  • Unclean hotel facilities

    “Carpets dirty and stained” “Hallways filthy”

Review highlights

Location

93/100
16 reviews

Great location.

“Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge” “Fantastic location”

Service

76/100
7 reviews

Fantastic service.

“Staff was very informative” “Staff were friendly and helpful” “Delightful staff”

Pool

72/100
22 reviews

Great but dirty pool.

“Pool and hot tub were excellent” “Pool area was awesome” “Pool was beautiful and very clean”

Amenities

57/100
23 reviews

Ordinary amenities.

“Muggy halls” “No A/C in the hallways” “Completely worn out carpeting at stairs”

Vibe

54/100
16 reviews

Decent vibe. Hotel is outdated.

“AC was newer” “Modern shower head” “Modern decoration”

Room

54/100
33 reviews

Rooms spacious and relatively new. Unclean, badly-maintained rooms and bathrooms.

“AC worked great” “Carpet is stained” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

Value

53/100
10 reviews

Fairly good value for money.

“Recommend this affordable resort” “Reasonably priced and clean place to stay” “Not worth the stay”

Cleanliness

34/100
20 reviews

Dirty rooms, bathrooms, and pool area. Unclean hotel facilities.

“Carpet is stained” “Moldy bath fixtures” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

Ranked top 51% by couples, with a score of 65

Good to know

  • Hotel is outdated

    “This place is old and run down” “Very old motel”

  • Dirty

    “Carpet is stained” “Moldy bath fixtures”

  • Dirty room

    “Carpet is stained” “Pillows were stained”

  • Great pool

    “Pool and hot tub were excellent” “Pool area was awesome”

Review highlights

Location

92/100
8 reviews

Great location.

“Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge” “Fantastic location”

Pool

72/100
11 reviews

Great pool.

“Pool and hot tub were excellent” “Pool area was awesome” “Pool was beautiful and very clean”

Amenities

57/100
12 reviews

Beautiful grounds but poor buildings, with so-so amenities.

“No A/C in the hallways” “Completely worn out carpeting at stairs” “Poorly maintained facilities”

Value

56/100
6 reviews

Fairly good value for money.

“Recommend this affordable resort” “Reasonably priced and clean place to stay” “Reasonably priced for the Keys”

Room

55/100
19 reviews

Relatively new rooms. Dirty room.

“AC worked great” “Dirty moldy carpet” “Beautiful water views”

Vibe

55/100
7 reviews

Decent vibe. Relatively modern hotel.

“AC was newer” “Modern shower head” “Modern decoration”

Cleanliness

35/100
13 reviews

Dirty room.

“Carpet is stained” “Moldy bath fixtures” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

Good to know

  • Great location

    “Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge”

  • Great pool

    “Pool and hot tub were excellent” “Pool area was awesome”

Review highlights

Location

93/100
5 reviews

Great location.

“Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge” “Fantastic location”

Pool

77/100
4 reviews

Great pool.

“Pool and hot tub were excellent” “Pool area was awesome” “Pool was beautiful and very clean”

Comfort

65/100
5 reviews

Comfortable.

“AC was newer” “No A/C in the hallways” “Sheets are quite worn”

Room

59/100
7 reviews

Room is all right.

“Excellent shower” “AC worked great” “Dirty moldy carpet”

Amenities

58/100
4 reviews

Ordinary amenities.

“No A/C in the hallways” “Completely worn out carpeting at stairs” “Poorly maintained facilities”

Vibe

56/100
5 reviews

Decent vibe.

“AC was newer” “Modern shower head” “Modern decoration”

Good to know

  • Average hotel building

    “Dated property” “Completely worn out carpeting at stairs”

  • Dirty room

    “Carpet is stained” “Pillows were stained”

Review highlights

Location

92/100
10 reviews

Great location.

“Close to nature trails” “Near 7 mile bridge” “Fantastic location”

Comfort

58/100
5 reviews

Comfortable.

“AC worked great” “Air conditioner was super loud” “Mattress needs to be updated”

Amenities

57/100
6 reviews

Hotel buildings are unacceptable but amenities are OK.

“Floors have been vacuumed” “Completely worn out carpeting at stairs” “Poorly maintained facilities”

Room

53/100
9 reviews

Rooms are acceptable but filthy.

“Excellent shower” “AC worked great” “Carpet is stained”

Vibe

51/100
4 reviews

Decent vibe.

“AC was newer” “Modern shower head” “Modern decoration”

Cleanliness

34/100
6 reviews

Dirty room.

“Carpet is stained” “Moldy bath fixtures” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

Review highlights

Pool

77/100
7 reviews

Great pool.

“Pool and hot tub were excellent” “Pool area was awesome” “Pool was beautiful and very clean”

Review highlights

Room

48/100
5 reviews

Room is not nice.

“Carpet is stained” “Moldy bath fixtures” “Carpet in the room was very dirty and stained”

Review Semantics by TrustYou

Customer Reviews of Banana Bay Resort & Marina

3.0 out of 5. Based on 462 guest reviews , Average

Property Description

Banana Bay sits on 10 acres of property on the bay side of Marathon. We have lush tropical vegetation and a laid back relaxed atmosphere. We offer the largest fresh water pool in the Keys. We are centrally located to Key Largo and Key West.

Details / Other Expenses

Check In: 3pm
Check Out: 11am
Year of Last Renovation: 2007
Floors: 2
Rooms: 62
Non Smoking Rooms: 50
Handicap Rooms:
Suites: 0
Meeting Rooms: 2
Meeting Space: 400 sq. feet
Banquet Space: Holds 30 people
Policies / Expenses
Cancellation:
7 days prior to arrival
Nightly Parking: 0.0
Typical Group Deposit: 1000.00
Total Taxes: 12.50%
Total Misc Fees: $6.00 USD
(mandatory resort fees/taxes)

Amenities / Features


Pet Friendly? Sorry, pets are not allowed.

  • Air conditioning
  • Alarm clock
  • Baggage storage facilities
  • Camping or barbeque facilities
  • Central location
  • Clothes drying
  • Complimentary breakfast
  • Concierge service
  • Conference facilities
  • Credit card accepted: Mastercard/Visa
  • Credit card accepted: American Express
  • Credit card accepted: Discover
  • Credit card accepted: Diners Club
  • Facilities for the disabled
  • Fax available
  • Hairdryer available
  • Handicap accessible
  • Ice Maker
  • Internet - wireless
  • Ironing facilities
  • Jacuzzi
  • Laundry facilities
  • Licensed bar
  • Non-smoking rooms
  • Office or business center
  • Private bathroom in room
  • Quiet location
  • Radio in room
  • Refrigerator
  • Self controlled heating/cooling system
  • Shower
  • Swimming pool - outdoor
  • Telephone in all rooms
  • Television
  • Tennis court
  • Travellers cheques accepted
  • Voicemail

Airport & Shuttle Information

2 miles from Marathon Airport 50 miles from Key West Airport 125 miles from Miami Airport 150 miles from Ft Lauderdale

Airport Shuttle? Sorry, no airport shuttle available.

Similar hotels near by

More Details >
Image of Sea Dell Motel
Sea Dell Motel ~0.26 Miles away

Testimonials: Why use Hotel Planner?

Testimonials icon
"It was great. I ended up booking my meeting with the best bid, that I wouldn't have received if it wasn't for you." C.C. - New York City, NY

Find Out More Check Rates