SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Buffalo

65 Us Highway 16 East, Buffalo, WY 82834 United States (USA) near Exit 299 on I-25 (~0.1km)
View Map Reservations: 1-800-219-2797
2.5 Star Property
44.354170-106.685080
+1-800-219-2797
AI Disclaimer

This tool is powered by OpenAI's ChatGPT service. We strive to provide 100% accurate and reliable data to our customers, but third-party content generated by AI, including OpenAI's ChatGPT, can sometimes make errors for various reasons, such as incomplete or inaccurate responses. We advise all customers to exercise caution and to use your best judgment regarding the fidelity of ChatGPT's responses.

Check availability
Very Good
4.5/5

Based on 293 guest reviews

Show Guest Reviews
  • We have an indoor pool ready for use
  • Free breakfast available
  • 63 sleeping rooms in hotel
  • Hotel has 2 floors
  • Check in: 03:00
  • Check out: 11:00
  • Group friendly rating of 7.2/10

Check current prices






Standard prices by room type for the next 60 days

Rates shown are nightly rates before taxes and do not necessarily reflect all discounts available. The chart provides the cheapest public rates available by room type.

Room Types

Check Rates1 King Bed
Non-Smoking
Check Rates1 King Bed Accessible
Non-Smoking
Check Rates1 King Bed Accessible Bathtub
Non-Smoking
Check Rates1 King Bed Accessible with Bathtub
Non-Smoking
Check Rates1 King Bed Bathtub Accessible
Non-Smoking
Check Rates1 King Bed Mobility Accessible
Non-Smoking
Check Rates1 King Bed Mobility Accessible Bathtub
Non-Smoking
Check Rates2 Double Beds
Non-Smoking
Check Rates2 Queen Beds Pet Friendly Room, Microwave and Refrigerator Flat Screen Television Table and Chairs H
Non-Smoking
Check RatesAAA CAA Rate Accessible 1 King Full Breakfast Accessible
Non-Smoking
Check RatesAccessibility 1 King Bathtub
Non-Smoking
Check RatesAccessible
Non-Smoking
Check RatesAccessible 1 King Accessible 1 King Accessible Bathtub Full Breakfast
Non-Smoking
Check RatesAccessible 1 King Full Breakfast Accessible
Non-Smoking
Check RatesAccessible 1 King Mobility Accessible Bathtub Full Breakfast
Non-Smoking
Check RatesAccessible Standard Room with 1 King Bed
Non-Smoking
Check RatesAccessible Standard Room with 1 King Bed and Bathtub
Non-Smoking
Check RatesDouble Accessible King Size Bed
Non-Smoking
Check RatesGovt Military Rate Show Gov ID At Check in Accessible 1 King Full Breakfast Accessible
Non-Smoking
Check RatesKing Room Disability Accessible
Non-Smoking
Check RatesMobility Accessible
Non-Smoking
Check RatesStandard King Bed Accessible
Non-Smoking
Check RatesStandard Room, King or Two Doubles
Non-Smoking

Local Attractions

Historical downtown Walking trails nearby Located in valley of Big Horn Mountains Prairie & mountain wildlife observations Hunting & fishing Small-town atmosphere

Landmarks and Location of SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Buffalo

Map is loading...
See Street View

Verified Reviews of SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Buffalo

Below are the verified reviews from guests that we have booked recently:
"Clean reasonable rates helpful friendly staff and towels and washcloths are thick and fluffy"
Overall Score5.0/ 5
We enjoyed our stay again. We stay here on every trip to Buffalo. Our room is always clean, our bed has always been comfortable, the staff is wonderful and I personally really love the thick, fluffy towels and washcloths! Rates are so reasonable. We've been staying here every year for 13 years and will continue to stay here when we come to Buffalo!
(Individual traveler, booked 1 room), from US flag
17-Jan-2026 Verified Review, stayed from Fri Jan 16 to Sat Jan 17 2026 at a $97.99 average nightly rate.
"Clean, comfortable and friendly."
Overall Score5.0/ 5
Would revcommend this hotel.
(Individual traveler, booked 1 room), from US flag
31-Aug-2025 Verified Review, stayed from Sun Aug 31 to Mon Sep 01 2025 at a $154.99 average nightly rate.
"Hot pool and good breakfast."
Overall Score4.0/ 5
Hot pool and good breakfast. Easy access location to the east or west.
(Individual traveler, booked 1 room), from TW flag
29-Aug-2025 Verified Review, stayed from Thu Aug 28 to Fri Aug 29 2025 at a $152.99 average nightly rate.
"Great personnel, great breakfast. Thank you!"
Overall Score5.0/ 5
We received great personal attention when cking in. Also, the breakfast was great. Clean rooms. All was perfect.
(Group coordinator, booked 2 rooms), from US flag
14-Jul-2025 Verified Review, stayed from Sat Jun 28 to Sun Jun 29 2025 at a $159.99 average nightly rate.
4.5 out of 5. Based on 293 guest reviews

Property Description

The Sure Stay Plus  Plus Hotel Buffalo is conveniently located near the crossroads of Interstates 25 and 90. We are along US Highway 16 which is part of the Cloud Peak Scenic route of the Big Horn Mountains. Also our location is between Yellowstone National Park approximately 235 miles west of hotel and Mount Rushmore approximately 240 miles east of hotel. Our 100% non-smoking building has 2 floors with an elevator. Free breakfast provides eggs, breakfast meat, waffles, various pastries and breads, yogurt, cold cereals, juice, coffee, and tea. The indoor pool and hot tub are open from 8 a.m. to 10 p.m. and the fitness room is available from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. The guest laundry is open 24 hours and has coin-operated machines. Limited number of rooms are pet-friendly with an additional daily fee of $20 per pet. Free parking is available with limited space for buses. Guests must be at least 18 years of age to register.

Details / Other Expenses

Check In: 03:00
Check Out: 11:00
Year of Last Renovation: 2019
Floors: 2
Rooms: 63
Corridors: Both Interior and Exterior Hallways
Non Smoking Rooms: 63
Handicap Rooms: 2
Suites: 0
Room Windows: Windows Do Open
Cleaning Frequency: Daily
Meeting Rooms: 0
Banquet Space: Holds 20 people
Dist. to Food/Bars: 0.4 Km
Dist. to Nearest Gym: On-site
Pool Info:
Indoor Pool & Indoor hot tub open 6:00 a.m. - 10:00 p.m.
Policies / Expenses
Cancellation:
24 Hours
Nightly Parking: 0
Typical Group Deposit: 50%
Total Taxes: 7.00%
Total Misc Fees: S$0.00 SGD
(mandatory resort fees/taxes)

Amenities / Features


  • Air conditioning
  • Alarm clock
  • Complimentary breakfast
  • Credit card accepted: Mastercard/Visa
  • Credit card accepted: American Express
  • Credit card accepted: Discover
  • Credit card accepted: Diners Club
  • Elevator
  • Fax available
  • Hairdryer available
  • Internet - wireless
  • Ironing facilities
  • Microwave in room
  • Non-smoking rooms
  • Office or business center
  • Pets allowed
  • Refrigerator
  • Restaurant
  • Swimming pool - indoor
  • Tea and coffee making facilities
  • Telephone
  • Telephone in all rooms
  • Telephone - Free local calls
  • Voicemail

Airport & Shuttle Information

30 Miles

Local Shuttle Info: none

Breakfast Information

Free hot breakfast

Pet Friendly?

Service animals complying with ADA Title lll regulations are allowed.

Yes! Pets are allowed.
Pets allowed based on the availability of pet friendly rooms. Up to 2 dogs per room with an 80 pound weight limit. Additional pet types (cats, birds, etc) may be accepted at the hotels discretion. Pet rate is $20.00 per day with a $100 per week maximum.

Parking Info

Free

Internet / WiFI

Free High Speed WIFI

About SureStay Plus

  • Great value with quality extras. Whether for leisure or business, SureStay Plus Hotels by Best Western is the perfect choice for those who like to travel simply and casually. Find the amenities and service you expect at SureStay Plus.

The SureStay Plus highlights above are subject to change without notice.

Previously known as:
Comfort Inn Buffalo

Similar hotels near by

More Details >
Exterior of Hampton Inn & Suites Buffalo
Hampton Inn & Suites Buffalo ~0.2 km away
More Details >
Exterior of Quality Inn Buffalo
Quality Inn Buffalo ~0.4 km away

FAQs about SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Buffalo

What time is check in?

Check in time is 03:00 based on the hotel's local time. Early check in may be available if requested at the front desk on the day of check-in.

What time is check out?

Check out time is 11:00 based on the hotel's local time. Late check out may be available if requested at the front desk during your stay.

How many rooms does SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Buffalo have?

There are 63 sleeping rooms in the hotel.

What kind of breakfast is at SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Buffalo?

Free hot breakfast

What parking is available at SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Buffalo?

Free

How much does internet cost?

Free High Speed WIFI

Can I get a AAA rate at SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Buffalo?

Yes, they have stay dates that support AAA hotel discounts. Example room type: AAA CAA Rate Accessible 1 King Full Breakfast Accessible

Can I get a Senior or AARP rate at SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Buffalo?

Sorry, this hotel does not offer senior hotel discounts at this time.

Is there a pool at SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Buffalo?

Yes, there is a pool on-site at the property. Indoor Pool & Indoor hot tub open 6:00 a.m. - 10:00 p.m..

Testimonials:

Testimonials icon
"Wedding planning is time consuming enough. This made the most use of my time without having to make mutiple phone calls. Thanks so much!" V.L. - Tempe, AZ

Learn More Check Rates