Bay Shore Inn

300 Bay Shore Rd., Bay Shore, NY 11706 United States (USA)
View Map Reservations: 1-800-760-7718
2.0 Star Property
Check availability
Not Good

Based on 22 guest reviews

Show Guest Reviews
  • Hotel has 72 rooms
  • Hotel has 2 floors
  • Check in time: 13:00
  • Check out time: 11:00
  • Group booking rating of 5.5/10

Check Current Prices

Include Discounts:

Standard prices by room type for the next 60 days

Rates shown are nightly rates before taxes and do not necessarily reflect all discounts available. The chart provides the cheapest public rates available by room type.

Room Types

Check Rates1 King Bed
Smoking    Non-Smoking
Check Rates1 King Bed Mobility Accessible
Check Rates1 Queen Bed Accessible
Check Rates1 Queen Bed Accessible 1 Queen Bed
Check Rates2 Queen Beds
Smoking    Non-Smoking

Local Attractions

Westfield South Shore Mall (5 miles), Tanger Outlet Stores (3 miles), South Shore Beaches (2 miles), Bay Shore (2 miles), Fire Island Ferry (2 miles)

Verified Reviews of Bay Shore Inn

Below are the verified reviews from guests that we have booked recently:
"It's just an older Hotel."
Overall Score2.0/ 5
Unfortunately, I left my PJ bottoms there and I have spoke to representative, immediately when I got home Sunday, only was there for an overnight stay for a Party. I have called twice since then and they WILL NOT SHIP my PJ bottoms to CT. According to the Manager, Fred, I offered my credit card # and everything. Today, Wednesday, 7/29 I was told again that the Manager REFUSED to send back, my comment was U must have a bunch of stuff from people that have forgotten! NOWERE IN THE HOTEL POLICY DOES IT SAY, ACRTICLES LEFT BEHIND WILL NOT BE RETURNED?.
(Individual traveler, booked 1 room), from US flag
29-Jul-2020 Verified Review, stayed from Sat Jul 25 to Sun Jul 26 2020 at a $91.53 average nightly rate.
1.5 out of 5. Based on 22 guest reviews

Property Description

The Bay Shore Inn is located 3 miles from the Fire Island Ferry and the South Shore Beaches. Both the Tanger Outlet Stores and Westfield South Shore Mall are within 5 miles. New York is less than 50 miles.The budget friendly Bay Shore Inn offers free parking and free wireless internet access. All 72 rooms feature cable TV with extended channels, free wireless internet access and air conditioning.

Details / Other Expenses

Check In: 13:00
Check Out: 11:00
Year of Last Renovation: 2008
Floors: 2
Rooms: 72
Non Smoking Rooms: 0
Handicap Rooms: 0
Suites: 0
Meeting Rooms: 0
Policies / Expenses

Airport & Shuttle Information

Long Island Mac Arthur (12 miles), John F Kennedy Intl (32 miles), Igor I. Sikorsky Mem. (88 miles), La Guardia (40 miles)

Airport Shuttle? Sorry, no airport shuttle available.

Pet Friendly?

Service animals complying with ADA Title lll regulations are allowed.

Sorry, pets are not allowed.

FAQs about Bay Shore Inn

What time is check in?

Check in time is 13:00 based on the hotel's local time. Early check in may be available if requested at the front desk on the day of check-in.

What time is check out?

Check out time is 11:00 based on the hotel's local time. Late check out may be available if requested at the front desk during your stay.

How many rooms does Bay Shore Inn have?

There are 72 sleeping rooms in the hotel.

Can I get a AAA rate at Bay Shore Inn?

Sorry, this hotel does not offer AAA hotel discounts at this time.

Can I get a Senior or AARP rate at Bay Shore Inn?

Sorry, this hotel does not offer senior hotel discounts at this time.


Testimonials icon
"Very impressed with the quick reply. Will recommend this site to fellow planners!!" M.M. - Camden, NJ

Find out more Check Rates