Star Rating
Hotel Name
Price Range (USD)to
Amenities

Shelter Island New York Hotels & Motels

Find accommodations in Shelter Island with the hotel list provided below. Find cheap and discounted hotel/motel rates in or nearby Shelter Island, NY for your personal leisure or group travel. We list the best Shelter Island, New York hotel and motel rooms. Browse the Shelter Island area hotels to find the perfect lodging! Please use the provided map of the Shelter Island hotels.

The Shelter Island center is around 4 miles southwest of Orient Point Park and 5 miles north of Old Whalers Church.

Shelter Island Hotels & Accommodations

Shelter Island House : 11 Stearns Point Rd. 11 Stearns Point Rd., Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 ~3.27 miles west of Shelter Island
  • High-end Beach hotel
  • Check-in time: 3:00pm
Baron's Cove 31 West Water St., Sag Harbor, NY 11963 ~5.21 miles south of Shelter Island
  • 4-star Resort property
  • 2 floors in property
Forever Bungalows 765 Rt 114, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 ~6.05 miles south of Shelter Island
  • Three Star hotel
  • 14 sleeping rooms in hotel
The Maidstone Hotel : 207 Main St.
+1-888-283-3404
207 Main St., East Hampton, NY 11937 ~9.97 miles southeast of Shelter Island
  • Expensive Beach property
  • 7 suites in property
  • Good amenities
  • Thorough cleaning
The Hedges Inn - East Hampton 74 James Lane, East Hampton, NY 11937 ~10.11 miles southeast of Shelter Island
  • Expensive Beach property
  • 13 rooms in property
From$400
Excellent 5.0 /5Guest Reviews CallBookMore Details
The Capri : 281 County Rd.
+1-866-429-5787
281 County Rd., Southampton, NY 11968 ~13.12 miles south of Shelter Island
  • Three Star Resort property
  • 25 rooms in hotel
  • Service is adequate
  • Room needs to be redecorated
Southampton Inn 91 Hill St., Southampton, NY 11968 ~14.15 miles south of Shelter Island
  • Affordable Resort property
  • Check in time: 4:00 PM
  • Great value for the money
  • About half of guests found the staff to be unfriendly
Saybrook Point Inn & Spa 2 Bridge St., Old Saybrook, CT 06475 ~14.64 miles north of Shelter Island
  • 3-star Riverfront hotel
  • Fitness / Gym is on-site
  • Lots of activities
  • Most guests found the staff to be very friendly
From$379
Very Good 4.5 /5Latest Reviews CallBookMore Details
Southampton Cottages : 35 Shrubland Rd.
+1-888-305-3366
35 Shrubland Rd., Southampton, NY 11968 ~14.85 miles southwest of Shelter Island
  • Expensive hotel
  • 20 suites in hotel
Atlantic Hotel in Southampton 1655 County Rd. 39, Southampton, NY 11968 ~14.88 miles southwest of Shelter Island
  • Three Star Golf Course hotel
  • 2 floors in property
  • Staff was friendly and accommodating
  • Array of breakfast options is great
The Bentley Southampton - Southampton 161 Hills Station Rd., Southampton, NY 11968 ~15.33 miles southwest of Shelter Island
  • Economical Highway hotel
The Hamlet Inn
+1-866-221-8581
300 Montauk Highway, Southampton, NY 11968 ~15.41 miles southwest of Shelter Island
  • 3 star property
  • Great location
  • Filthy floors
Pier Blue Guesthouse : 1430 Boston Post Rd. 1430 Boston Post Rd., Old Saybrook, CT 06475 ~15.61 miles north of Shelter Island
  • 2 star Beach property
  • 50 sleeping rooms in hotel
Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook
+1-888-690-5281
1750 Boston Post Rd., Old Saybrook, CT 06475 ~15.77 miles northwest of Shelter Island
  • Cheap Suburban property
  • Check-in: 2:00pm
  • Every guests reviewed thought it was pleasantly quiet
  • Clean
Super 8 Motel
+1-888-690-5247
37 Spencer Plain Rd., Old Saybrook, CT 06475 ~15.91 miles northwest of Shelter Island
  • Two-star Oceanfront property
  • Check in time: 02:00 PM
  • Ironing board included
  • Good accessibility by car
Waters Edge Resort & Spa 1525 Boston Post Rd., Westbrook, CT 06498 ~15.92 miles northwest of Shelter Island
  • Midscale property
  • Great indoor gym
  • Bar great
Gurneys Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa 290 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY 11954 ~16.49 miles east of Shelter Island
  • Three Star Beach hotel
  • Hotel has 20 suites
  • No lift
  • Steep hillside
From$250
Very Good 4.0 /5Review Score CallBookMore Details
Quality Inn Old Saybrook 100 Essex Rd., Old Saybrook, CT 06475 ~17.06 miles north of Shelter Island
  • Mid-scale Suburban hotel
  • Check-in time: 3:00pm
  • Excellent value
  • Great location
The Bee & Thistle Inn in Old Lyme 100 Lyme St., Old Lyme, CT 06371 ~17.39 miles north of Shelter Island
  • 4 star Riverfront property
  • Hotel has 4 meeting rooms
From$173
Very Good 4.5 /5Hotel Reviews CallBookMore Details
Beachcomber Resort at Montauk : 727 Old Montauk Highway
+1-866-429-5787
727 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY 11954 ~17.92 miles east of Shelter Island
  • Four star Beach hotel
  • 2 floors in property
  • Comfortable
  • Reception is all right
Montauk Manor : 236 Edgemere Rd.
+1-888-690-5281
236 Edgemere Rd., Montauk, NY 11954 ~18.11 miles east of Shelter Island
  • 4 star Beach hotel
  • 4 floors in property
  • The price was too high for 67%
  • Unspectacular architecture
A Wave Inn in Montauk 32 South Elmwood Ave., Montauk, NY 11954 ~18.63 miles east of Shelter Island
  • Low-priced Beach hotel
  • 2 floors in property
Bowen's by The Bays 177 West Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays, NY 11946 ~18.82 miles southwest of Shelter Island
  • Mid-scale property
Montauk Yacht Club Resort Hotel & Marina in Montauk
+1-800-881-1523
32 Star Island Rd., Montauk, NY 11954 ~18.99 miles east of Shelter Island
  • Midscale Lake property
  • 103 rooms in hotel
  • Room is all right
  • Nice balcony
From$125
Very Good 4.0 /5Latest Reviews CallBookMore Details
Bayview Resort 53 West Tiana Rd., Hampton Bays, NY 11946 ~19.38 miles southwest of Shelter Island
  • 3 star Oceanfront property
  • 26 rooms in hotel
Next 25 Shelter Island Hotels >  [1 - 25 of 50]    
Next: See My Shelter Island Hotels with Pricing
Back to Top