Star Rating
Hotel Name
Price Range (USD)to
Amenities

Shelter Island New York Hotels & Motels

Find accommodations in Shelter Island with the hotel list provided below. Find cheap and discounted hotel/motel rates in or nearby Shelter Island, NY for your personal leisure or group travel. We list the best Shelter Island, New York hotel and motel rooms. Browse the Shelter Island area hotels to find the perfect lodging! Please use the provided map of the Shelter Island hotels.

The Shelter Island center is around 4 miles southwest of Orient Point Park and 5 miles north of Old Whalers Church.

Shelter Island Hotels/Accommodations

Shelter Island House in Shelter Island Heights
+1-888-690-5247
11 Stearns Point Rd., Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 ~3.27 miles west of Shelter Island
  • 4 star Beach property
  • 11 rooms in property
Baron's Cove
+1-888-305-3366
31 West Water St., Sag Harbor, NY 11963 ~5.21 miles south of Shelter Island
  • High end Resort hotel
  • Gym / Fitness Center Available
Sound View Greenport in Greenport
+1-800-881-1523
58855 Route 48, Greenport, NY 11944 ~5.28 miles west of Shelter Island
  • Mid-scale property
  • Hotel has 2 floors
Forever Bungalows : 765 Rt 114
+1-888-283-3404
765 Rt 114, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 ~6.05 miles south of Shelter Island
  • 3-star hotel
  • 14 rooms in property
Room at the Beach
+1-866-221-8581
2668 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton, NY 11932 ~9.44 miles south of Shelter Island
  • Midscale hotel
  • Check-in time: 15:00
Topping Rose House - Bridgehampton
+1-866-429-5787
1 Bridgehampton Sag Harbor Tpke, Bridgehampton, NY 11932 ~9.50 miles south of Shelter Island
  • Luxury Five Star Beach hotel
  • 3 floors in hotel
From$175
Very Good 4.0 /5Hotel Reviews CallBookMore Details
The Baker House 1650 : 181 Main St.
+1-888-690-5281
181 Main St., East Hampton, NY 11937 ~9.91 miles southeast of Shelter Island
  • High-end property
The Hedges Inn
+1-888-690-5247
74 James Lane, East Hampton, NY 11937 ~10.11 miles southeast of Shelter Island
  • High end Beach property
  • Hotel has 3 floors
From$400
Excellent 5.0 /5Latest Reviews CallBookMore Details
East Hampton House Resort
+1-888-305-3366
226 Pantigo Rd., East Hampton, NY 11937 ~10.12 miles southeast of Shelter Island
  • 3 star hotel
  • Check in time: 15:00
Journey East Hampton - East Hampton
+1-800-881-1523
490 Pantigo Rd., East Hampton, NY 11937 ~10.34 miles southeast of Shelter Island
  • 4-star Beach property
  • Free breakfast available
The Capri
+1-888-283-3404
281 County Rd., Southampton, NY 11968 ~13.12 miles south of Shelter Island
  • Midscale Resort hotel
  • Comp. Breakfast
  • Honest hotel
  • Service is ok
The Hermitage at Napeague
+1-866-221-8581
2148 Montauk Highway, New York, NY 11930 ~13.23 miles east of Shelter Island
  • 3 star hotel
  • 50 rooms in hotel
Windward Shores
+1-866-429-5787
2062 Montauk Highway, New York, NY 11930 ~13.23 miles east of Shelter Island
  • 3-star hotel
  • 45 rooms in property
Southampton Inn - Southampton
+1-888-690-5281
91 Hill St., Southampton, NY 11968 ~14.15 miles south of Shelter Island
  • Midscale Resort property
  • Check in time: 4:00 PM
  • Furniture old
  • Complimentary bottles of water
The Ocean Colony Resort
+1-888-690-5247
2004 Montauk Highway, New York, NY 11930 ~14.33 miles east of Shelter Island
  • 3 star property
  • Check-in time: 15:00
Saybrook Point Inn & Spa in Old Saybrook
+1-888-305-3366
2 Bridge St., Old Saybrook, CT 06475 ~14.64 miles north of Shelter Island
  • Midscale Riverfront property
  • 6 suites in property
  • Rooms are outstanding
  • Great location
From$199
Very Good 4.5 /5Guest Reviews CallBookMore Details
Seacrest at Amagansett
+1-800-881-1523
2166 Montauk Highway, Islip, NY 11930 ~14.87 miles east of Shelter Island
  • Midscale hotel
  • Check in time: 15:00
Atlantic Hotel in Southampton
+1-888-283-3404
1655 County Rd. 39, Southampton, NY 11968 ~14.88 miles southwest of Shelter Island
  • Mid-scale Golf Course hotel
  • 4 suites in property
  • Easily accessible by car, said 80%
  • Room needs to be redecorated
The Bentley Southampton
+1-866-221-8581
161 Hills Station Rd., Southampton, NY 11968 ~15.33 miles southwest of Shelter Island
  • Low priced Highway hotel
  • Check-in time: 3:00
Pier Blue Guesthouse in Old Saybrook
+1-866-429-5787
1430 Boston Post Rd., Old Saybrook, CT 06475 ~15.61 miles north of Shelter Island
  • Two-star Beach property
  • Complimentary breakfast is offered
Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook - Old Saybrook
+1-888-690-5281
1750 Boston Post Rd., Old Saybrook, CT 06475 ~15.78 miles northwest of Shelter Island
  • 2-star Suburban property
  • Complimentary breakfast is offered
  • Breakfast is mediocre
  • Excellent value
Waters Edge Resort & Spa in Westbrook
+1-888-690-5247
1525 Boston Post Rd., Westbrook, CT 06498 ~15.92 miles northwest of Shelter Island
  • Affordable Beach property
  • Check-in time: 3:00pm
  • Scenic seaside location
  • Breakfast is mediocre
Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook
+1-888-305-3366
37 Spencer Plain Rd., Old Saybrook, CT 06475 ~15.99 miles northwest of Shelter Island
  • Low Cost Oceanfront property
  • Check in: 02:00 PM
Ocean View Terrace Inn & Suites : 285 East Montauk Highway
+1-800-881-1523
285 East Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays, NY 11946 ~16.70 miles southwest of Shelter Island
  • Midscale Beach property
  • Check-in: 3pm
Quality Inn Old Saybrook : 100 Essex Rd.
+1-888-283-3404
100 Essex Rd., Old Saybrook, CT 06475 Website ~17.06 miles north of Shelter Island
  • Three Star Suburban hotel
  • Hotel has 3 floors
  • Great value for the money
  • Most guests said the wifi quality was bad
Next 25 Shelter Island Hotels >  [1 - 25 of 50]    
Next: See My Shelter Island Hotels with Pricing

Graph: Upcoming 20 Days of Shelter Island Hotel Rates

Rates shown are nightly rates before taxes and do not necessarily reflect all Shelter Island, NY discounts available. The chart reflects the cheapest Shelter Island hotel for each day and each star rating category.

FAQs about hotels in Shelter Island

What are the most favored hotels in Shelter Island?

The Hedges Inn, Saybrook Point Inn & Spa and The Bee & Thistle Inn are the best rated hotels based on customer reviews in the last 365 days.

What are the most up-scale hotels in Shelter Island?

Topping Rose House, Shelter Island House and Baron's Cove are the top 3 luxury hotels near Shelter Island city center.

What hotels are closest to the city center of Shelter Island?

Shelter Island House, Baron's Cove, and Sound View Greenport are the properties closest to Shelter Island city center.

What are the best independent hotels in Shelter Island?

The Hedges Inn, Saybrook Point Inn & Spa and The Bee & Thistle Inn are the best rated independent hotels (not part of a big brand).

What are the best Choice Hotels branded hotels in Shelter Island?

Quality Inn Old Saybrook, Rodeway Inn and Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook are the best rated Choice Hotels branded hotels (based on HotelPlanner reviews score).

Back to Top