There are several state parks in Montauk and beautiful beaches that you can enjoy year-round, but the town is busiest during the summer months.
When to Visit Montauk, NY
Montauk is at peak season during the summer months. From Memorial Day to Labor Day expect hotels to charge higher rates. It is also when all the restaurants, cafes, and parks are open to the public. August is particularly busy in Montauk, and you can expect the beaches and state parks to be packed with visitors.
The shoulder seasons of spring and fall are ideal times to visit if you want to enjoy the sights and shops while they're still open, but don't want to fight the crowds. Hotel prices tend to drop during these times, too.
In early spring the weather is still pretty chilly, but seasonal restaurants begin to open again and you can still walk along the beach and check out some of the national parks.
The weather in early fall is still nice and warm, and Montauk is a beautiful place to see the colors of fall foliage as the season begins to change. Colors begin changing in early October and you can appreciate it best at local state parks, like Hither Hills or Montauk Downs.
Winter is the low-season in Montauk. It's when the area is quietest and you'll get the lowest rates for hotels. If you want to enjoy a weekend of walking on empty beaches and relaxing in cozy cafes in the afternoons, then winter is an ideal time for you to visit Montauk.
Below is a chart of the current pricing seasonality of hotels and motels in Montauk, NY:
Montauk by Star Rating
Below are 3 charts demonstrating mean nightly cost trends by star rating class in Montauk, NY. You can use these charts to determine the cheapest months to book a room in Montauk for your upcoming travels.
Luxury Hotels in Montauk, NY
4 Star Average Prices: $294.25
East Hampton is a place known for its luxury, so it's no surprise that Montauk is full of fantastic luxury hotel options. One of the best is the Montauk Blue Hotel. The Montauk Blue Hotel is located right on the waterfront. You're within walking distance of Kirk Park Beach and only a short drive or bike ride away from Shadmoor State Park.
The Montauk Blue Hotel is packed with amenities such as an indoor pool, a spa tub, and high speed internet. For a real splurge, be sure to book a room with an ocean view so you can sit on your balcony and soak up the sunshine.
Another choice for a luxury hotel in Montauk is Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa. The resort is right on the beach and every room has an ocean view with a balcony. Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa has a full-service spa where you can indulge in facials, manicures, and massages.
The resort also has an outdoor pool, an indoor pool, a fitness center, and a hair salon. There are three restaurants where you can dine for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, and a cafe to grab coffee or cakes in. The resort has a private beach with lounge chairs and a beach bar so you never even have to get up from your spot.
Affordable Hotel Options in Montauk, NY
3 Star Average Prices: $266.52
If you're looking for an affordable hotel right in the center of Montauk, then book yourself a room at Kenny's Tipperary Inn. It's located a mile and a half from Montauk Downs State Park and five miles from the tip of the island where you can see the Montauk Lighthouse.
All 33 rooms at Kenny's Tipperary Inn have refrigerators, flat-screen televisions, and a balcony where you can sit and enjoy the view with a morning coffee. The hotel also has an outdoor pool, an on-site restaurant, and a garden with lounge chairs to relax in.
If you're going to be taking the ferry to Montauk from New London, Connecticut, the Hampton Inn Groton is a great affordable hotel where you can spend the night on either end of your trip. It's less than two miles from the New London Amtrak station and right down the road from the ferry terminal. The hotel has complimentary Wi-Fi, an indoor pool, and a fitness center. Your stay also includes a free hot and cold buffet breakfast in the morning.
Another great affordable option near the ferry terminal in Connecticut is the Howard Johnson Inn Mystic. The rooms have recently been remodeled and they are full of natural light and bright colors. If you wanted to explore Mystic before heading to Montauk, the hotel is right near all the big attractions like the Mystic Aquarium and the Mystic Seaport Museum.
2 Star Average Prices: $226.77
Which Montauk hotels have real discounts?
If you're looking for a good discount from a hotel near Montauk, Budget Host Inn East End offers AAA discounts, senior discounts, and military personnel discounts. They offer up to 10 percent off their regular room rates, depending on what month you want to visit.
The hotel is located in Riverhead, New York, about 40 miles west of Montauk, but is still surrounded by beaches and great restaurants. You can easily drive to Montauk for a day trip or use the Budget Host East End Hotel has a base to explore East Hampton. The hotel offers guests complimentary Wi-Fi and has an outdoor pool to enjoy during the summer months.
Greenview Inn Riverhead also offers military discounts to those that bring their military IDs with them when they check-in. Receive up to 10 percent off your room rate throughout the year. The Greenview Inn is also in Riverhead, near Wildwood State Park and Ashley Beach. All guest rooms have microwaves, refrigerators, and flat-screen televisions with satellite programming.
Best Value Options Montauk, NY
If you're looking for good value hotels near Montauk, the Sea Haven Resort Motel is a great choice. It's located in Southampton, about 35 miles from the center of Montauk and a short drive to all of the best beaches in the area. It's also less than five miles away from Agawam Park, a beautiful place to relax and to find events throughout the year.
The Sea Haven Resort Motel isn't just a great deal on price, it is also offers plenty of amenities. Every room comes with free Wi-Fi, flat-screen televisions with cable, and a microwave. There is ample free parking available and there's even space for RVs and coach buses. If you want to self-cater, grab some supplies from the nearby grocery store and use one of the barbecues available in the garden and have a nice summer picnic as the sun goes down.
Best Restaurants in Montauk, NY
Montauk is a haven for New Yorkers during the summer months. Thanks to the growing popularity of East Hampton, tons of restaurants have cropped up over the years and many of them are beloved by both locals and tourists. Whether you want to indulge in a seafood banquet or enjoy a simple meal with fresh, local ingredients, you're bound to find a few restaurants in Montauk that you love.
For the best local seafood, you need to book yourself a table at South Edison. It's located right along the beach, so you can enjoy ocean views while you dig into dishes like lobster bisque, seared yellowfin tuna, and whole grilled fish. There's also an extensive raw bar with fresh Montauk oysters available daily. The menu is seasonal, so be sure to check out the restaurant throughout the year.
If you want to head somewhere to celebrate a special occasion or just enjoy a fine-dining meal, East by Northeast is a wonderful option. It's an Asian fashion restaurant that takes flavors from Japanese, Korean, and Chinese cuisine and mixes them with the fresh local produce of the Northeast. They have everything from steak to duck tacos and sushi rolls. Be sure to book in advance during the busy summer months.
Zum Schneider brings Bavaria to Montauk. This German restaurant and beer hall along the beach seamlessly mixes pork knuckles and steins of beer with Montauk surf culture. The sausages and pretzels will make you feel like you're in Bavaria, but one look outside will remind you that you're right by the beach in downtown Montauk. This is a popular spot all day long and the long communal tables mean you don't have to wait long to be seated.
Whether you're looking for a luxury escape to East Hampton or you want to find an affordable option nearby Montauk, there are many great hotels to choose from. If you want to explore the area during the summer, be sure to book well in advance so that you get the best possible rates, and don't forget how great Montauk can be in the shoulder seasons.